Health Insurance May Not Help Your Case

stethoscope image

Health insurance is supposed to be there to help us, for OUR benefit. The California Supreme Court, in the Howell v. Hamilton Meats case, decided that while you might get your medical bills covered by your health insurance but any discount your health insurance company negotiates for you on paying those bills is not a benefit for exclusively for you. The Court said that any person who causes you harm is also entitled to that benefit when it comes time to compensate you for your incurred medical expenses. Often times this also means that the value of your pain and suffering is reduced because auto insurance companies, adjusters, judges and juries all look at your medical expenses as a determining factor in how much to compensate you for physical suffering.

Your Health Insurance Company May Benefit More Than You

One additional consequence of the Court’s opinion, probably unintended, is that there is no longer any motivation to submitting medical bills to health insurance for payment. Other than getting the bills paid (which benefits only the health care provider), there is no benefit to the injured person. There is more value in letting the bills linger in collections or on a statutory lien for their “full amount” rather than having the bills paid at a reduced rate which only benefits the auto insurance companies and ultimately distorts the value of your valid injury claim.

In essence, consumers are being punished for trying to plan for an unfortunate accident, and being punished again by giving someone who causes harm the benefit of your buying health insurance. The solution is to take the issue up with our Legislature: convince our legislators that the Court misapplied the law and that the health insurance consumer is losing the intended benefit of health insurance. Otherwise, the critical element of damages is depressed, distorted and under compensated. Ultimately the entire system will become retarded because it will be more beneficial to those injured in accidents to let their medical bills go unpaid.

Every Health Insurance Case Is Different

You must contact a competent personal injury attorney to find out if using your health insurance is to your advantage. Our Lawyers have the experience and are here to help keep you from being taken advantage of.

Recent Blog Posts

  • student injured at school - parents suing for negligence

    Suing a School for Negligence: What You Need to Know

    A negligence-based lawsuit against a school can have unique complications, depending on the type of institution it is. Overall, teachers, school administrators, and other staff have a “duty of care,” meaning they must take reasonable steps to avoid and prevent circumstances likely to cause personal injury to a student. Some reasons you might want to […]

    Read More
  • a stereotypical biker who could be unfairly blamed for motorcycle accident

    California Bill Could Have Ended Motorcycle Profiling

    In February of this year, a bill was introduced by Assembly Member Anna Caballero (D-Salinas) that would have it illegal for law enforcement officials to engage in “motorcycle profiling.” The successful passing of this bill likely would have had a significant impact on future California motorcycle accident cases. Co-authored by Speaker Pro Tempore Kevin Mullin (D-South San […]

    Read More
  • classroom where a school accident might happen

    Can You Sue if Your Child Suffers Personal Injury at School?

    Laws about whether or not you can file a lawsuit against a school vary from state to state. In California you certainly can, but first you must file a Notice of Claim within six months of the date of injury. School districts are government entities and as such are protected by what is known as […]

    Read More
  • Sacramento Office
  • 333 University Avenue, Suite 200
  • Sacramento, CA
  • (916) 756-0772
  • Roseville Office
  • 1544 Eureka Road, Suite 120
  • Roseville, CA
  • (916) 788-1960
  • Oakland Office
  • 1300 Clay St, Suite 600
  • Oakland, CA
  • (510) 962-4610

© 2018 Penney Law, Serving the Areas of Sacramento, Roseville, Fairfield, Modesto, Stockton & Oakland California